| Year | Name |
| 1958 | Anna Badame |
| 1959 | Diane Everly |
| 1960 | Diane Hull |
| 1961 | Linda Harbick |
| 1962 | Pam James |
| 1963 | Barbara Richartz (Campanella) |
| 1964 | Jean Richartz (Longmire) |
| 1965 | Donna Steinmetz |
| 1966 | Andrea Davis (Rambo) |
| 1967 | Kathy Prickett |
| 1968 | Barbara Bierce |
| 1969 | Joan Williamson |
| 1970 | Sue Mathis |
| 1971 | Christine Hartman |
| 1972 | Cara Simons |
| 1973 | Geri Mansi Johnson |
| 1974 | Liz McDonald |
| 1975 | Robin Lee |
| 1976 | Julie Zelesnick |
| 1977 | Denise Hurd Law |
| Year | Name |
| 1978 | Kathy McCusker (Zale) |
| 1979 | Cyndee Ragone |
| 1980 | Denise Higbee (Faust) |
| 1981 | Patti Burns |
| 1982 | Kelly Hopkins |
| 1983 | Barbara Jean Campanella |
| 1984 | Michele Roi |
| 1985 | Jeanine Warrington |
| 1986 | Debora Stens |
| 1987 | Dory Hohenberger Valeriano |
| 1988 | Lorraine Swallow Shields |
| 1989 | Kristie Vogel |
| 1990 | Margaret Zeoli |
| 1991 | Rosemary Andacie-Martin |
| 1992 | Maureen Fitzgerald |
| 1993 | Karen Cunningham Mitchell |
| 1994 | Nicole Forsyth |
| 1995 | Kristin Clement |
| 1996 | Nichole Starinieri Bianco |
| 1997 | Kristen McKenna |
| Year | Name |
| 1998 | Lauren Ciccarelli |
| 1999 | Kristen Miller |
| 2000 | Serena Rebecca |
| 2001 | Alexis Torres |
| 2002 | Lauren Boswell |
| 2003 | Sara Baxter |
| 2004 | Brianna Jeanne Campanella |
| 2005 | Jill Doyle |
| 2006 | Christina Mottola |
| 2007 | Madelynn Scott |
| 2008 | Lindsay Kellum |
| 2009 | Kalyn Meyers |
| 2010 | Noelle Cinquino |
| 2011 | Karley Hall |
| 2012 | Courtney O’Neill |
| 2013 | Jennifer Abbott |
| 2014 | Christina Moffett |
| 2015 | Mya Wence |
| 2016 | Kayla Johnson |
| 2017 | Kayla Johnson |
| Year | Name |
| 2018 | Alexis Lomanno |
| 2019 | Jamie Kaufman |
| 2020 | Julia Filipkowski |
| 2021 | Catherine Tully |
| 2022 | Catherine Tully |
| 2023 | Haley Lucier |
| 2024 | Briana Schwartz |
| 2025 |
| Year | Name |
| 2020 | Madison Previglian |
| 2021 | Grace Taylor |
| 2022 | Grace Taylor |
| 2023 | Emma Burke |
| 2024 | Carly DeHaven |
| 2025 |